Nov 08 2011

Misha Glenny, the Greek oligarchs and the offshore laundry

Posted by: Nick Shaxson in: Thoughts

Something I just wrote for the Tax Justice Network:

Misha Glenny has a nice piece in the FT today:

As the new Greek government struggles to convince Europe of its resolve to cut the country’s bloated public sector, it also has to decide whether to face down the real domestic threat to Greece’s stability: the network of oligarch families who control large parts of the Greek business, the financial sector, the media and, indeed, politicians.

The oligarchs have responded predictably: by accelerating their exports of cash. In the last year, the London property market alone has reported a surge of Greek money. And then there’s this, of course, not strictly a core tax justice issue, but these things are all intertwined:

Their aim is clear – they are waiting to pounce on the state assets which, under the various bail-out plans, the Greek government must privatise. The oligarch conglomerates are waiting to scoop them up at anything up to less than a fifth of their real value – a poor financial return for the state but in 5-10 years time a bonanza for the purchasers. Some have been even banking on Greece exiting the euro so that they can then use the billions of euros squirrelled away outside the country to purchase the assets for knock-down drachma prices.

We’ve seen this pattern in country after country, particularly since the 1970s.

  1. Élites loot a state.
  2. Élites take their loot offshore,
  3. State, desperate for cash, is forced to sell off assets.
  4. Currency plunges as ever more cash drains offshore
  5. Élites bring money back, often disguised as foreign investment through offshore secrecy structures, then use their connections to obtain those privatised assets at knock down prices.
  6. Currency plunge make élites’ offshore dollars worth more in local currency than when they shipped their cash out, boosting profits.
  7. Offshore secrecy structures (sometimes) help élites rig local markets, boosting their profits at citizens’ expense
  8. Government receipts plunge, citizens must pay more taxes
  9. Profits are remitted offshore again, outside the tax net
  10. Citizens pay the taxes that they won’t.

And so the dance goes on.

Now a longish quote from Treasure Islands:

“Financial deregulation and globalisation? Offshore is at the heart of the matter, as we shall see. The rise of private equity and hedge funds? Offshore. Enron? Parmalat? Long Term Capital Management? Lehman Brothers? AIG? Offshore. Multinational corporations could never have grown so vast and powerful without tax havens. Goldman Sachs is very, very much a creature of offshore. And every significant financial catastrophe in the world since the 1970s, including the latest global economic crisis, is very much an offshore story. The decline of manufacturing industries in many advanced countries has many causes, but offshore is a big part of the tale. Tax havens have been central to the growth of debt in our economies since the 1970s. The growth of complex monopolies in certain markets, or insider trading rings, or gigantic frauds, almost always involve secrecy jurisdictions as major or central elements

This is not to say that all of these problems don’t have other explanations too; they always do. Tax havens are never the only story, because offshore exists only in relation to elsewhere. That is why it is called offshore. Without understanding offshore, we will never properly understand the history of the modern world.

For the record, Glenny gives Papandreou considerable credit for at least trying to fight against these interests.

For Greece, the big question is whether after Mr Papandreou, the country possesses the requisite political talent and vision both to introduce root-and-branch reforms in order to revive the cankerous institutions of state, and to halt the pillaging of the Greek economy by its wealthiest and most powerful citizens. This is something that the country’s international creditors might wish to ponder, too.

To make matters worse, the Swiss are hoping to sell them a deal whereby those elites get to cement their secrecy, while paying almost no tax, and politicians in Greece and elsewhere are falling for it. It makes you want to weep.

9 comments so far

Alien Edouard 11th November, 2011 11.59 am

“To make matters worse, the Swiss are hoping to sell them a deal whereby those elites get to cement their secrecy, while paying almost no tax, and politicians in Greece and elsewhere are falling for it.”

Oh Nicholas…. Could you not get your facts right? The Swiss are not hoping to sell anything to the Greeks. Horst Reichenbach (quoted in your link to Bloomberg) is a senior official helping to facilitate an agreement between Switzerland and Greece along the lines of the previous deal between Switzerland and Germany. The initiative comes from the EU.

Nick Shaxson 11th November, 2011 4.08 pm

Alienedouard, you claim to have read the document from the uk-swiss tax deal, and even praised it – and then your comment reveals that you haven’t read it, or at least all of it. Our document demonstrates beyond all doubt that this is a deal cooked up by Swiss bankers and then presented – via the Swiss authorities – to foreign governments.

Do feel free to apprise yourself of the facts before commenting. It will save everyone’s time.

Greek 11th November, 2011 9.56 am

The notion that Papandreou stood against big interests is risible, to say the least.

The mechanism described by Misha Glenny (destroy a country, then buy it out for peanuts) is indeed in full swing in Greece. Both foreign and Greek oligarchs will benefit from it, although some previously powerful Greek corporations will be destroyed in the process, making their bosses a lot less rich.

In any case, Papandreou, has done his best to facilitate this process of pillaging.
No doubt his successor will continue on the same path.

Alien Edouard 11th November, 2011 11.55 am

Nick – I praised section 3 of the documents which detailed the potential technical loopholes.

I have read the rest of the document, including the sections 4.2 which you are presumably referring to. Even if the Swiss bankers had the original idea, it is not like they had they could unilaterally force Germany to accept it, could they? Could it be, maybe, that they put forward a pragmatic, workable solution whose merits Germany recognized?

And anyway the point remais: Horst Reichenbach is a German senior official o fthe EU and he is the one recommending that Greece concludes a similar deal. He is not a Swiss banker.

Nick Shaxson 11th November, 2011 8.51 am

So if it worked like you did, why did they claim huge revenues for this thing when I have shown that the revenues can only be a small fraction of what is claimed? Swiss bankers whispering into journalists’ ears are influential people, and these fantastic, outlandish claims of tens of billions continue to swirl around, and that gets people licking their lips.

Alien Edouard 11th November, 2011 9.53 am

Nick – you have NOT shown that the revenues can omnly be a small fraction of what is claimed. You have identified a few loopholes in the agreement which (i) may lead to some revenue leakage but in an amount that you are totally unable to quantify, (ii) may still be amended in the German-Swiss treaty, and (iii) which certainly could be removed in a future Greek-Swiss deal.

You are about the only person thinking that these deals will not generate any revenue. It looks like a case of “I am right and everybody else is wrong”. Good luck with that.

And again, it is an EU official being quoted about the revenue-raising potential of a Greek-Swiss deal, not a Swiss banker.

Nick Shaxson 11th November, 2011 10.18 am

Alienedouard, I am very busy and you really are wasting my time, I’m afraid. You have clearly not read the full article we wrote. It looks at the numbers very carefully, then puts an absolute upper limit on them. It is pretty much unarguable. Go and read it first, please. i have better things to do.

[…] Misha Glenny, the Greek oligarchs and the offshore laundry | Treasure Islands: Tax Havens and the me… […]

[…] in a similar fashion like Ecuador was forced to give up their rainforest, while the local Greek oligarchs that control large parts of Greek businesses, financial sector, the media and politicians have also […]

Leave a comment

*